Myopia Profile


Complex myopia cases: unilateral myopia with high astigmatism

Posted on May 3rd 2022 by Connie Gan

Sponsored by


Every now and then, when you think you've got myopia control all figured out, a tricky case like this will present. How do you manage unilateral myopia with high astigmatism? JS shared a case with the Myopia Profile Facebook community involving a teen who is hyperopic in one eye, myopic in the other, and highly astigmatic in both eyes. Here are the details.

JS Here’s an interesting challenge that was referred to me by a local anterior eye ophthalmologist for myopia control and I’d love to hear your thoughts on how to proceed, please. She’s 16yo, both parents are Caucasian with a history of wearing SV distance glasses. Right AL is 23.37mm and the Left is 26.37mm, A-scan on 4/2/20, with no earlier AL readings Spec script history is limited: 19/02/13: R +1.50/-3.75x163 L -3.00/-2.00x27. 9/3/19: R +1.75/-4.25x152 6/6 L -5.50/-3.00x40 6/12-2 25/10/19: R +1.75/-4.25x152 6/6 L -5.75/-3.25x40 6/12-2 14/05/20: +1.50/-4.50x157 6/6-1 L -6.75/-4.00x31 6/12-2 Opthal has ruled out keratoconus and topo maps confirm high corneal toricity. My plan is to 1. fit her with corneal RGPs 2. use 0.02% atropine bilaterally to slow the AL elongation in the left eye. 3. Visual hygiene/frequent breaks from nearwork, with lots of outdoor time with less screentime, are strongly encouraged. 4. Check in 3 months to see if the RGP has improve her VA, and assess her binocularity/Phorias. Semi-scleral lenses are the backup plan if the corneal lenses don’t align or are too uncomfortable to wear. Would you add or remove anything from the plan above?jscase.jpg
JS PH VA 6/15 and VA with RGP was also 6/15 with a high over-Rx so I expect the corrected VA to improve as the over-Rx reduces.JS The right eye's flat K is 41.61, and the left eye's is 42.24.

When a patient is hyperopic in one eye and myopic in the other, this is called antimetropia. Antimetropia is rare and management can be complex. The prevalence of antimetropia in a Korean study of 1100 patients was 0.2%.1 Antimetropia can cause amblyopia - the greater the refractive error difference between the eyes, the typically poorer vision in the amblyopic eye.2 Hence, in such cases, one may find themselves with competing clinical priorities to attend to.

JS offers us his management plan:

  1. To firstly fit the patient with corneal RGPs in order to optimize visual acuity in the left, myopic eye
  2. Consider prescribing 0.02% atropine bilaterally to slow the axial elongation in the myopic eye.
  3. Recommend visual hygiene, frequent breaks with near work and increased outdoor time.
  4. Review in 3 months to check for improved VA and a binocular vision workup.

Do you agree with this plan?

NB Good plan, especially BV workup in 3 months when acuity maximised - I would do it then regardless of VA progress and not wait for that extra line.PC Good plan. Maximising VA in both eyes and providing better binocularity should help. I think suppression is the driver for her LE progression…

Most commenters agreed with this plan of management - focusing first on improving visual acuity in the left eye with an RGP fit for high myopia and astigmatism, followed by assessing and enhancing binocular vision status, then reassessing the patient for myopia control.

Is there anything else we can add?

As there is no textbook treatment for this patient, we shall tease out the various considerations in our approach to managing monocular myopia with high astigmatism.

Other contact lens options

GN … Could consider “partial” OK with overspecs for residual...pending some lens design thoughts.HB Have you considered hybrid CD MFs?DS …OrthoK is an option. I think the bigger priority is to maximise the vision in each eye…GA Orthok custom for mixed astigmatism with toric BOZ is not bad idea.NB Most of cyls is corneal so a Myopia Control custom designed with toric periphery Should work well .PC … Even if you did orthoK on her LE you would still need to correct her RE with CL or glasses, and there may be some residual cyl correction for her LE.

The most popular alternative contact lens option was orthokeratology (OrthoK) lenses with spectacles correcting residual myopia and/or astigmatism. OrthoK could be pursued to offer both myopia correction and a myopia control effect for the left eye.

Partial orthokeratology treatment has shown efficacy for myopia control: in the High Myopia-Partial Reduction Orthokeratology (HM-PRO) study, children with at least -6.00D of myopia were corrected to -4.00D with OrthoK, and their residual refractive error corrected with single vision distance spectacles. The myopia control effect was similar to that found in studies in which full refractive correction was achieved with OrthoK lenses.3

OrthoK is also the only intervention for myopia control which shows efficacy for myopia in combination with higher astigmatism. The TO-SEE study corrected children with between 1.25D and 3.50D of astigmatism with OrthoK, and found again a similar myopia control effect to that in children in other studies with lower astigmatism.4

It is worth noting two things for this case.

  1. The child has 4.00D of astigmatism in her left, myopic eye. Astigmatism correction to this level of astigmatism has not been studied.
  2. The child is 16 years old. A meta-analysis of the myopia control efficacy of orthokeratology included studies with children aged 6-16 years5 so this is evidence-based treatment based on age, but at the upper limit.

The other suggestion was to fit the child with a centre-distance multifocal hybrid lens, which involves an RGP optical centre with a soft contact lens skirt.  This could be an option for vision correction, but there are no studies on use of this lens for myopia control.

Partial orthokeratology treatment has shown efficacy for myopia control: in the High Myopia-Partial Reduction Orthokeratology (HM-PRO) study, children with at least -6.00D of myopia were corrected to -4.00D with OrthoK, and their residual refractive error corrected with single vision distance spectacles. The myopia control effect was similar to that found in studies in which full refractive correction was achieved with OrthoK lenses.3

Binocular vision

BS ...Typically such high anisometropia indicates a major binocularity problem.SG Chances are she’s suppressing her left eye to some degree. BV workup essential.DS … I suspect that the explanation here is physical in origin and not accommodative. Binocularity may not have been fully present for some time and assessment of binocularity May hold limited value until best corrected visual acuity is optimised in each eye.

We should always investigate a patient's binocular visual status when they have anisometropia or antimetropia. In anisometropes, stereoacuity can be reduced due to amblyopia and optical effects of correction.6 Stewart et al showed improved stereoacuity after amblyopia treatment.7 Therefore, the focus on improving left eye visual acuity may serve to improve the binocularity, and the improved binocularity may in turn reduce the rate of myopic progression. This assumption is based on reducing retinal blur, a driver for myopia progression,8 as there is no data on myopia progression in amblyopia.

Is there keratoconus?

TM The topographies show classic asymmetrical bow-ties. I will bet this is Keratoconus and needs to be watched carefully. I would therefore suggest yearly tomography scansJS …I don't fully agree with you atm because an anterior eye ophthalmologist has ruled out keratoconus at this stage but it might develop as you say so I'll keep that in mind as time goes by.

Due to high levels of corneal toricity, one of the commenters was suspicious of keratoconus. However, the patient's ophthalmologist had already ruled it out. It is still worthwhile monitoring the topography annually if there is any suspicion of corneal ectasia.

This is not a normal myopia

NR This is “nothing like normal myopic progression” so all bets off. Any form of attempt at Myopia management is off-label and [outside of] published research. Fit best Toric RGP to maximise visual acuity and manage normally. Anything else is a waste of time because you have no target or start point. This is genetic not “peripheral imaging shells" driven JS Agreed, I've dropped the idea of atropine and am focussed on getting the RGP to fit properly. Thanks for your thoughts and comments.

Most myopia control research typically does not include patients with anisometropia or amblyopia, therefore good patient communication is needed to avoid overpromising and to ensure informed consent.5

OrthoK, however, does hold the distinction of being the only intervention for which there is evidence of myopia control in anisometropia, indicating slower growth of the more myopic eye as well as slower overall growth of both eyes.9 Read more in this Myopia Profile Science Review.

Interestingly, throughout discussion of this case, the managing eye care professional JS decided to abandon the idea of prescribing atropine for myopia control in the first instance, and instead focus on achieving the best possible acuity for the left eye with high myopia and astigmatism.

A similar case study

Makino10 described a similar case of monocular myopia with astigmatism in a 10-year-old boy with a refraction of right (R/OD) -6.00/-2.00×170 and left (L/OS) +1.50/-2.00×5. Despite normal best-corrected acuity in each eye (6/6 or 20/20), the boy was found to have right esotropia and hypertropia. He also had a tilted disc and inferior staphyloma in the right eye. This illustrates the need to explore other driving factors that lead to anisometropia or antimetropia, and highlights the necessity of full anterior and posterior ocular health assessment. This child was treated with full refractive correction with prism, and good binocular vision function was reported.

Take home messages:

  1. Ensure a full evaluation of ocular health for any abnormalities that may be a cause of anisometropia and especially amblyopia.
  2. The priority in these atypical myopia cases is to firstly optimize vision and binocularity - in this case, the high ametropia led to prescribing of a corneal RGP lens. Myopia control can often be a lesser priority in these cases, although some optical treatments for myopia can offer the benefit of both correcting myopia and providing a potential for slowing myopia progression.
  3. Be diligent in communicating the expectations for any myopia control strategies which are not studied or off-label, as might occur in these atypical cases.

Meet the Authors:

About Connie Gan

Connie is a clinical optometrist from Kedah, Malaysia, who provides comprehensive vision care for children and runs the myopia management service in her clinical practice.

Read Connie's work in many of the case studies published on Connie also manages our Myopia Profile and My Kids Vision Instagram and My Kids Vision Facebook platforms.

About Kimberley Ngu

Kimberley is a clinical optometrist from Perth, Australia, with experience in patient education programs, having practiced in both Australia and Singapore.

Read Kimberley's work in many of the case studies published on Kimberley also manages our Myopia Profile and My Kids Vision Instagram and My Kids Vision Facebook platforms.

This content is brought to you thanks to unrestricted educational grant from

Back to all articles

Enormous thanks to our visionary sponsors

Myopia Profile’s growth into a world leading platform has been made possible through the support of our visionary sponsors, who share our mission to improve children’s vision care worldwide. Click on their logos to learn about how these companies are innovating and developing resources with us to support you in managing your patients with myopia.